BEDS5
BATHS2 full 1 partial
SQUARE FEET2,845
MLS#1004894
STATUSActive
PROPERTY TYPEResidential - Single Family
SCHOOLShelter Island
Property Description
Dating back to the original 1871 layout of the Shelter Island Grove and Camp Meeting Association, Spring Garden Avenue is celebrated for its organic, rolling streetscapes and preserved 19th-century architecture. 5 Spring Garden Avenue is an authentic 1880 Victorian residence that embodies the classic style of the era, from its steeply pitched rooflines to its expansive exterior woodwork.The interior layout is expansive and true to its vintage, characterized by distinctive octagonal rooms on both the first and second floors. With five bedrooms, a sprawling third-floor attic loft, and a substantial footprint of covered decks and porches, the home offers a generous canvas within a historic setting.A significant structural update was completed in 2008, replacing the older foundation with a new poured concrete basement and structural footings, alongside the installation of a new roof. Featuring access to the Shelter Island Heights Association tennis courts and beach club, this property represents an authentic piece of island history.
Property Features
Property Type: Residential - Single Family
Basement: Yes
Basement: Bilco Door(s), Full, Storage Space, Unfinished, Walk-Out Access
Cooling: Multi Units
Fireplaces: 1
Heating: Propane
Home Style: Victorian
Lot Size: 0.25 Acres
Taxes: $7,153
Year Built: 1880
Amenities
Formal Dining
High Ceilings
Original Details
Pantry
Primary Bathroom
Soaking Tub
Walk Through Kitchen
Feature Descriptions
Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Refrigerator, Washer
Association Fee: $6466/Annually
Association Fee Includes: Sewer, Water
Attic: Walkup
Building Area Total: 2845
Exterior: Wood Siding
Fireplace Features: Family Room
Fireplace Y/N: Yes
Formal Dining: Yes
House Faces: South
On Market Date: 2026-05-27
Other Structures: Shed(s)
Parcel Number: 0700-005-00-04-00-023-000
Parking Features: Driveway
Rental Term: Monthly
Rooms Total: 10
Sewer: Public Sewer
Special View Info: Neighborhood, Panoramic
Utilities: Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected
Water: Public
Local Schools
High School: Shelter Island School
Middle School: Shelter Island School
Elementary School: Shelter Island School
School District: Shelter Island
Estimate Your Payment
Estimated Payment
$ 8,618.40 per month $7,584.82 Principal & Interest $596.08 Property Tax $437.50 Homeowner's InsuranceChange Payment Information
Listed By / Shown By
Listing By
Agency Name: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Agency Contact: 631-749-1155
Shown By
Agent Name: Toni Dagata
Agent Phone: Cell: (516) 901-4825
Agency Title: Coldwell Banker American Homes
Member Participants (and their affiliated licensees, if applicable) shall indicate on their websites that IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, that the data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by MLS GRID, and that the use of the MLS GRID Data may be subject to an end user license agreement prescribed by the Member Participant’s applicable MLS if any and as amended from time to time. MLS GRID may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Member Participant, and/or their MLS from liability.
Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
This site is hosted, designed and copyright
© 1994 - 2026 by
Delta Media Group, Inc. -- Patent Pending --
Agent License Information: Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
5 Spring Garden Avenue | MLS# 1004894
This single family home located at 5 Spring Garden Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965 is currently listed for sale with an asking price of $1,500,000. This property was built in 1880 and has 5 bedrooms and 2 full and 1 partial baths with 2845 sq. ft. Spring Garden Avenue is located within the Shelter Island school district. Search Shelter Island Heights real estate on tonidagata.cbamhomes.com today.